Find out which of these Caribbean islands is right for you.
When choosing between Puerto Rico and Barbados for your next Caribbean getaway, it can be tricky to make a decision. Both are very inviting and they both have different charms. It takes around 2 hours to fly between the islands so it’s advisable to pick one over the other. We generally don’t advise combining both islands in the same trip. So, what exactly differentiates one island from the other? Let’s take a deep dive and find out which one is right for you.
Culture and Heritage
Puerto Rico is a U.S. territory with a fascinating mix of Spanish, African, and Indigenous influences. From the cobblestone streets of Old San Juan to the rhythms of salsa and reggaetón, the island is a rich mix of cultures. History buffs will enjoy exploring El Morro fortress and the colorful colonial buildings of San Juan, while foodies can indulge in mofongo and piña coladas.
About Out Of Office
Out Of Office is a luxury tailor-made travel company with a focus on delivering exclusivity and inclusivity. Our passion for global adventure is matched only by our deep commitment to delivering exceptional five-star service.
Everything we do is customised and designed especially for you – our valued customer – based on your exact personal requirements. Each member of our team is widely travelled. This means you get access to first-rate travel insights and the best possible advice from our team of luxury travel experts.
| Enquire Now |
Barbados, on the other hand, blends its British colonial past (it recently became a republic) with Afro-Caribbean traditions. Its festivals, like Crop Over, showcase the island’s love of music and dance. Now that they’ve dropped the monarchy, their de facto head of state is Rihanna, the most famous Barbadian of them all.
The Best Gay-Friendly Caribbean Islands
Beaches and Natural Beauty
Barbados is famed for its coastline. The west coast, known as the “Platinum Coast,” is home to calm, crystal-clear waters, ideal for swimming and snorkeling. On the east coast, dramatic waves draw surfers to Bathsheba Beach. Meanwhile, Crane Beach is a major draw with its pink-hued sand and dramatic cliffs.
Puerto Rico also has beautiful beaches but offers a different kind of natural diversity. From the bioluminescent bays of Vieques and Mosquito Bay to the lush El Yunque Rainforest, the island is a treasure trove for eco-adventurers. Sun-seekers will love Flamenco Beach on Culebra, often ranked among the world’s best, while thrill-seekers can explore Puerto Rico’s underground caves or zip-line through its mountains.
Book Sandy Lane Hotel – Barbados
Adventure and Activities
In Barbados, you can go snorkeling with sea turtles, sail on catamaran cruises, and golf on world-class courses. For a taste of adventure, visit Harrison’s Cave or hike through Welchman Hall Gully.
In Puerto Rico, adventure takes center stage. Kayak through glowing bioluminescent bays, hike in the rainforest or explore ancient TaÃno cave carvings. The island’s nightlife, particularly in San Juan, is perfect if you’d like to explore nightlife, while the nearby islands of Vieques are ideal if you prefer a quieter retreat.
Book A Luxury Trip To Puerto Rico
Accessibility and Accommodation
For U.S. travelers, Puerto Rico’s status as a U.S. territory makes it incredibly convenient. There’s no need for a passport, and the dollar is the local currency. The island offers a wide range of accommodations, from luxury beachfront resorts to boutique hotels and eco-lodges.
Barbados, while a bit further afield, is well-connected to major international hubs and caters to luxury travelers with its stunning resorts and villas. It’s ideal for those looking for a more exclusive, high-end Caribbean experience.
The Best Gay-Friendly Hotels In The Caribbean
Gay-Friendly Travel
Both destinations are welcoming to LGBTQ+ travelers, but they differ in their levels of inclusivity. Puerto Rico, with its LGBTQ+ scene in San Juan, prides itself on being one of the most progressive destinations in the Caribbean. The island hosts annual Pride events and boasts a range of gay-friendly bars, clubs, and accommodations. Its legal framework supports LGBTQ+ rights, including same-sex marriage.
Barbados, while making strides in LGBTQ+ acceptance, remains more culturally conservative. Same-sex relations were decriminalized in 2022, and while luxury resorts are welcoming and inclusive, discretion is still advised in public settings. That said, the island’s commitment to improving LGBTQ+ inclusivity is encouraging and makes it an ever more attractive destination.
Book A Puerto Rico Culinary Tour
Which Should You Choose, Puerto Rico or Barbados?
If you’re drawn to gay nightlife, historical sites, and adventurous activities, Puerto Rico might be your ideal destination. It’s perfect for travelers who want a mix of cultural immersion and natural beauty, all with the convenience of staying within U.S. borders. Barbados, on the other hand, is a more laid-back, luxurious destination. Its stunning beaches, world-class dining, and 5-star hotels make it one of the most popular Caribbean islands.
