Two of the world's most dramatic wilderness destinations: here's how Patagonia and Iceland compare
Both Patagonia and Iceland sit in that category of destinations people describe as “once in a lifetime.” Vast landscapes, dramatic scenery, and a sense of being far removed from everyday life. But they deliver that experience in very different ways, and for a honeymoon, the differences matter.
The LGBTQ+ Angle
Iceland has one of the most progressive records on LGBTQ+ rights anywhere in the world. Same-sex marriage has been legal since 2010, an openly gay man served as prime minister, and Reykjavik Pride is one of the most celebrated events in the city’s calendar.
Argentina is comparably strong. It was the first country in Latin America to legalize same-sex marriage, also in 2010, and has built a comprehensive legal framework around LGBTQ+ rights in the years since. Buenos Aires has one of the most vibrant gay scenes in South America, and that confidence extends to the country’s hotels and operators, who have considerable experience with same-sex couples. If the honeymoon itself matters to you as an occasion, both countries handle it well.
Verdict: A tie. Both are among the world’s most welcoming destinations for LGBTQ+ travelers. Iceland is marginally more socially progressive at a cultural level; Argentina compensates with a bigger, more energetic urban gay scene.
Argentina is a country of dramatic contrasts, and nowhere is that more evident than on a journey that ends in Antarctica. This itinerary brings together the very best of the country, from the energy and elegance of Buenos Aires to...We Suggest...
Argentina and Antarctica: Journey to the End of the World
Tailor-Made Vacation
Getting There
From the US, both destinations are reasonably accessible. Iceland is around five to six hours from New York or Boston, with direct flights on Icelandair and other carriers, making it one of the easier long-haul options from the East Coast.
Patagonia requires flying to Buenos Aires first, around 11 hours from Miami or 14 to 15 from New York, and then a further two to three hours on a domestic flight to El Calafate or Ushuaia. It is a longer journey, though most couples find it easy to absorb into the itinerary with a night or two in Buenos Aires at the start.
From Europe, Iceland is genuinely close. London to Reykjavik is around three hours, and the short flight time makes it feasible as a longer weekend escape or a more substantial trip without the commitment of a long-haul journey. Patagonia from Europe involves a full transatlantic flight to Buenos Aires, typically around 14 hours with a connection, before the onward domestic leg.
Verdict: Iceland wins on accessibility, particularly for European couples or anyone on the US East Coast who wants a shorter journey. Patagonia is a longer, more committed trip, but the scale of the destination rewards it.
Argentina is one of the few destinations that can carry a honeymoon from start to finish without compromise. You have the energy and culture of Buenos Aires, the slower rhythm of Mendoza’s wine country, and the scale of Patagonia, all...We Suggest...
A Gay Honeymoon in Argentina: Buenos Aires, Wine Country and Patagonia
Tailor-Made Vacation
Luxury Hotels
Iceland’s luxury offer is concentrated but distinctive. The Retreat at Blue Lagoon is the headline property, built around private lagoon access, spa treatments and a level of seclusion that is hard to replicate anywhere in northern Europe.
Deplar Farm in the remote Troll Peninsula is an all-inclusive converted farmhouse lodge with heli-skiing, a private spa and Northern Lights viewing from a wild location. Hotel Rangá in the south is the pick for Northern Lights access combined with strong local character, while Ion Adventure Hotel near Thingvellir offers design-led wilderness immersion. Reykjavik itself has the Edition and Hotel Borg for couples who want an urban base with serious style.
Patagonia’s luxury lodge scene is more developed. The best properties here are purpose-built for an all-inclusive experience that combines exceptional accommodation with expert guided access to extraordinary landscapes.
Tierra Patagonia, overlooking Torres del Paine and holder of three Michelin Keys, sets the benchmark. Awasi Patagonia assigns each villa its own private guide and 4×4, making it the most genuinely exclusive option in the region. Explora El Chaltén is the right base for the Fitz Roy area, while Eolo Lodge sits on a 10,000-acre private estancia between El Calafate and the Perito Moreno Glacier. For the Ushuaia leg, Los Cauquenes on the Beagle Channel delivers the views and the spa in the right combination.
Verdict: Patagonia has the edge for couples who want the luxury lodge experience as the centerpiece of the trip. Iceland has two or three world-class properties and a strong Reykjavik offer, but Patagonia’s lodge infrastructure is more consistently exceptional across the whole journey.
Nature and Wildlife
Iceland’s natural theater runs year-round but changes character dramatically by season. In winter, the Northern Lights are the defining draw, alongside glacial ice caves, frozen waterfalls and a landscape that feels genuinely otherworldly under snow.
In summer, the midnight sun keeps the light extraordinary around the clock, and whale watching off the coast is excellent. The Golden Circle covers geysers, tectonic rift valleys and waterfalls in a single day. Glacier hiking on Vatnajökull and snorkeling between the tectonic plates at Silfra are experiences that exist nowhere else on earth.
Patagonia operates on a larger and wilder scale. The Perito Moreno Glacier, one of the few advancing glaciers in the world, calves house-sized chunks of ice into a turquoise lake in a way that is genuinely difficult to prepare for. The granite spires of Torres del Paine and the Fitz Roy massif offer some of the most dramatic mountain scenery anywhere in the Southern Hemisphere.
Peninsula Valdés on the Atlantic coast brings southern right whales, orcas, elephant seals and Magellanic penguins into remarkably close proximity. Condors circle overhead in the mountain passes. The sheer size of the wilderness, and the sense of being genuinely far from anywhere, is Patagonia’s defining quality.
Verdict: Both are extraordinary, but for different reasons. Iceland’s nature is more concentrated and more varied in a smaller area. Patagonia’s nature is bigger, rawer and in some respects more overwhelming. If glaciers and wildlife are the priority, Patagonia; if volcanic landscapes and the Northern Lights are the draw, Iceland.
The Verdict
Choose Iceland if you want a shorter journey, a more compact trip that combines city and wilderness, the Northern Lights, and a destination you can do well in under two weeks. It suits couples who want adventure alongside genuine comfort without committing to the far end of the world.
Choose Patagonia if you want the full wilderness lodge experience, landscapes on an almost incomprehensible scale, and a honeymoon that feels like a rare and committed journey. It rewards couples who are willing to travel further and stay longer.
Both are fully welcoming of LGBTQ+ couples. Both will deliver the kind of trip you talk about for years. The question is simply which kind of extraordinary you’re looking for.
Both destinations reward getting the details right, and both have properties that book up well in advance. Whether you’re drawn to the glaciers and granite spires of Patagonia or the volcanic landscapes and Northern Lights of Iceland, Out Of Office can build the trip around your own preferences.
